Malta challenged again over autumn finch trapping
Two court rulings have already gone against Malta. The European Commission is now challenging the rules used to catch seven species of wild finch in three more autumns.
A migrating Hawfinch or Siskin passing through Malta this autumn was covered by a national scheme allowing wild finches to be caught for research. The European Commission says the exemption has served a different purpose: it argues that Malta is allowing recreational trapping to continue under a scientific label. On 19 November it called on the country to stop authorising the practice.
The Commission's reasoned opinion concerns seven species. Alongside Hawfinch and Siskin, the rules cover Chaffinch, Linnet, Goldfinch, Greenfinch and Serin. At issue is the deliberate capture of free-living birds. The fact that a bird may be released afterwards does not, in itself, take its capture outside the protections of the EU Birds Directive.
The distinction matters because the directive allows exceptions, including for research, under strict conditions. Malta's stated interest has been in the origins of birds passing through the islands. A bird carrying a ring fitted abroad can connect a Maltese record to a known place and date. Malta's report on its 2020 scheme discussed the foreign rings recovered and argued that further recoveries were needed. The dispute turns not on whether a ring can yield useful information, but on whether the scheme is genuine research and whether the information could be obtained another way.
“does not pursue a genuine research purpose” European Commission, describing Malta's current derogation
That is the Commission's assessment, not a fresh judgment. It says that changes Malta made in 2025 weakened enforcement and reduced the role of scientists from the European Union for Bird Ringing. The Maltese government says it amended the law in response to the court and supplied further reasons why it considered there was no satisfactory alternative.
| Date | What changed |
|---|---|
| 2018 | The EU court found against Malta's recreational trapping exemptions. |
| September 2024 | The court found the subsequent research scheme breached the directive. |
| November 2025 | The Commission opened the present infringement proceedings with a formal notice. |
| November 2026 | A reasoned opinion challenges the renewed autumn exemptions. Malta has two months to respond. |
The 2024 judgment dealt with the scheme established after the earlier recreational exemptions. Malta nevertheless authorised further autumn seasons in 2024, 2025 and 2026. Those later authorisations, and aspects of their implementation not decided by the court then, are why the Commission has taken a further step rather than simply republishing the old ruling.
Malta's ministry says it intends to continue discussions with the Commission. If the response does not resolve the objections, the Commission may refer the case to the Court of Justice. The new opinion neither imposes a fine nor establishes that an individual trapper has committed an offence.
20 November 2026
Get Breaking Birdnews First
Get all the latest breaking bird news as it happens, download BirdAlertPRO for a 30-day free trial. No payment details required and get exclusive first-time subscriber offers.
