footer_shadow

International reputation of Scotland 'blighted' by wildlife crime says RSPB

The Scottish Government has released its annual wildlife crime report covering the calendar year 2016.

The headlines included;

  • An overall reduction by 8% in recorded offenses compared to 2015
  • Crimes against birds down slightly
  • Hunting with dogs offences nearly doubles
Missing satellite-tagged birds such as Golden Eagles, are not included in the crime report figures (© Andy Willams)

Writing in the foreward Cabinet Secretary for the Environment, Land Reform and Climate Change Roseanna Cunningham said; "Encouragingly this is the lowest number recorded for the past 5 years and is mirrored in the Police Scotland Raptor Persecution data, with a 19% decrease in recorded offences. I hope to see this downward trend continue.”

Indeed this would be encouraging if it wasn’t for the fact that the report only covers recorded crime and does not include incidents where satellite-tagged birds go missing in suspicious circumstances. This despite a report commissioned by Scottish Government, which showed that between 2004 and 2016 as many as 41 out of 131 satellite-tagged Golden Eagles disappeared (presumed died). The report concluded that "Overall… a relatively large number of the satellite-tagged golden eagles were probably killed, mostly on or near some grouse moors where there is recent, independent evidence of illegal persecution.”

In response to the report, Duncan Orr-Ewing, Head of Species and Land Management for RSPB Scotland, said: "We welcome the publication of the Wildlife Crime in Scotland Report for 2016, and the continued scrutiny by the Scottish Government of this issue. Sadly, wildlife crime, including the illegal killing of our of native birds of prey, remains a blight on the international reputation of Scotland, and in our view stronger sanctions are urgently required to act as a deterrent.

"At the end of May 2017, an official report into the fate of satellite tagged golden eagles showed that many of these birds were disappearing in suspicious circumstances, primarily on land managed for driven grouse shooting. As a result, an independent enquiry has now been launched by the Scottish Government into how grouse moors can be managed sustainably and within the law, including consideration of options for a licensing system.

"We believe that an effective licensing system for driven grouse shooting, including sanctions to remove licences to operate where illegal activity is confirmed, could help tackle persistent criminality, and promote the required culture change in this sector. It would of course also provide safeguards for those land managers who operate responsibly. We look forward to giving evidence to this independent enquiry in due course.

"The disappearing satellite tagged golden eagles, along with other similar occurrences to hen harriers, give a strong indication that the wildlife criminals have not stopped their activities, and instead may have changed their methods in order to avoid detection. This context needs to be taken into account when interpreting the data presented in the Wildlife Crime in Scotland Report."

 

11 December 2017

Share this story

 

 

 

 

freetrial-badge

Latest articles

article_thumb

RBA Round-up: 13 - 19 Nov

Jon Dunn brings you his weekly look-back at the best birds from Britain, Ireland and the Western Palearctic. More here >

article_thumb

Iceland weighs spring shooting permits for Whooper Swans

A motion before Iceland's parliament would put birds returning from Britain and Ireland within reach of shooting permits on farmland, including during the breeding season. More here >