Shooting organisations announce intention to move towards removing lead shot
After decades of pressure nine UK shooting organisations have announced that they want an end to lean ammunition on live quarry by 2025. Interestingly they have not committed that the change will happen, rather it is their aim.
The news was welcomed by many conservationists but many also cautioned that previous voluntary bans have been unsuccessful and without policy change at government level, there will still be risks to human health, wildlife and the market for game birds.
Responding to the news Wildfowl and Wetlands Director of Conservation Dr James Robinson said: “Lead is a poison, and we should be taking every step possible to remove it from our environment. We are therefore delighted to see this leadership coming from within the shooting community itself.”
“Lead shot is currently banned on all wetlands in Scotland and Northern Ireland. In England and Wales, there is a ban on using lead shot to shoot wildfowl and over certain wetlands, but repeated research in England found poor compliance with more than 70% of ducks shot illegally with lead. Given such poor compliance with current regulations, it is important that concrete actions are taken by shooting organisations to encourage their members to use non-toxic ammunition before it is removed completely. We look forward to hearing about the substance of these next steps and how WWT can help.”
It has been difficult to persuade shooters of the scale of the deaths caused by lead poisoning because dead and dying birds are usually taken quickly by predators – making their deaths unseen and ‘invisible’ to shooters and the wider public alike. In the UK, it is estimated that approximately 75,000 wildfowl (between 50,000 and 100,000) die from lead poisoning each winter. ( From the paper Poisoning of birds and other wildlife from ammunition-derived lead in the UK)
Lead is known to affect the developing brain and nervous system, and the UK Food Standards Agency states that there is no agreed safe level for lead. Independent scientific experts across the European Union advise that exposure to lead should be reduced as far as possible, especially for children and pregnant women.
Writing on his blog Dr.Mark Avery said: “Government has been pitifully slow in doing anything about this subject and now they can hide behind this announcement, which may not be delivered on the ground (most other promises haven’t been) for several more years.”
“My heroes on this subject are the members of the Lead Ammunition Group, especially its chair, the former BASC boss, John Swift, who changed his mind in response to the evidence and knowing that his former colleagues would attack him viciously (which they did).”
“Waitrose are heroes too. They led the way among supermarkets and that was writing on the wall.”
“But the main hero is a heroine too – Debbie Pain. She has been active on this issue, both as a scientist and an advocate, for decades. She deserves more of the credit for this change of position than anyone else, in my view, and she too has been reviled by shooting interests for years and years.”
Raptor Persecution UK were quick off the mark with their usual forensic analysis and quickly blogged that the Scottish Gamekeepers Association have rejected the call for a voluntary ban.
RPUK said; “For as long as these dinosaurs are left to their own devices don’t expect to see a voluntary reduction in the use of lead ammunition in Scotland any time soon.”
25 February 2020
Share this story
