Justice for Ravens crowdjustice appeal raises £10k in 12 hours
A crowdfunding campaign to fund a judicial review of Scottish Natural Heritage’s decision to grant a license for a Raven cull in Highliand Perthshire, secured it’s initial funding target of £10,000 within just 12 hours of being launched yesterday.
The campaign was launched by Ruth Tingay on behalf of the Scottish Raptor Study Group. In recent weeks 168,000 signed a petition calling for an immediate withdrawal of the license, questions were raised in the Scottish Parliament and yet SNH decided to carry on regardless.
Although the organisers have managed to secure the services of a formidable QC working for reduced rates further funds are likely to be needed if the judge deems the case strong enough to proceed further.
In response to the campaign an RSPB Scotland spokesperson said: “We recognise that this is a hugely controversial issue and the decision to permit a cull generated a significant level of concern from the public and interested stakeholders. Given these concerns we think it would be helpful to have the process which underpinned that decision tested in the courts.
There has been no reaction from SNH so far, who could still withdraw the license at any time.
The CrowdJustice page is open until Wed 4th July and the current ‘stretch target is £25,000. So if you haven’t already supported the campaign please consider doing so today.
Here is the details of the campaign with links to background information and the all important link to pledge your support.
In April 2018, Scottish Natural Heritage (SNH) issued a licence permitting gamekeepers to kill young ravens across a large area called Strathbraan, in Highland Perthshire. Much of Strathbraan is managed for grouse shooting and the area has been identified as a wildlife crime hotspot. Further details about this controversial licensing decision can be found here.
This licence forms part of a planned five year 'experiment' to kill ravens in this area 'just to see what happens' to wading bird populations. However, peer-reviewed scientific studies suggest ravens are not responsible for wader population declines and we believe that this raven cull is actually to protect red grouse, which will later be shot for fun.
Gamekeepers have long campaigned to be allowed to kill ravens because they are perceived as a threat to grouse stocks, despite the charismatic raven only recently making a comeback from historical persecution.
We believe this licensing decision is unlawful because lethal control of a protected species like the raven should be a last resort and the decision should be based on sound scientific evidence, not on the basis of 'just to see what happens'. We also believe SNH should have officially consulted with a range of stakeholders before making this decision, to allow informed scrutiny of the licence application. Instead, SNH undertook the licensing process in secret, excluding the Scottish Raptor Study Group who have monitored ravens in this region for 30+ years.
Due to these concerns, and because SNH has indicated that a similar approach may be adopted for other species (probably buzzards), we intend to launch a legal challenge in the form of a judicial review of SNH's decision to issue this licence.
We have a fantastic team of highly-experienced legal experts in place to take forward our case (including a formidable QC who has kindly offered to work at reduced rates), but in order to proceed we need funding, and we're asking for your help. Initially we need to raise £10k to get to the first stage of judicial review - this is where a judge decides if we have a strong enough case to proceed to a full hearing.
If the judge deems our case is strong enough, we can then proceed to stage 2 (the full hearing) but we will then require further funding (amount TBA) to cover subsequent costs.
At the moment, we're raising funds to reach our first target (£10k). We cannot proceed until this funding is in place. We won't launch the second crowdfunding appeal until we know we have been successful at stage one.
Obviously, we cannot guarantee that our case will be successful, and that's the risk we all take when we make donations to support legal action like
this, but we feel strongly that this is a risk worth taking, not only for the ravens but to prevent SNH making similar unjustified decisions to permit the killing of protected raptors 'just to see what happens'.
We hope you will help support us in getting #Justice4Ravens
THANK YOU!
Ruth Tingay, on behalf of the Scottish Raptor Study Group
6 June 2018
Share this story

